Is Evidence Gathered by a Private Investigator Admissible in Court?

Whether for divorce and family law investigations, personal injury lawsuits, or insurance fraud investigations, Personal investigators are called on daily for their expert advice and ability to ferret out evidence that might otherwise be left in uncovered.

Since the information is obtained without the knowledge and consent of the investigated party, many consumers are concerned with the legality of such evidence and its admissibility in court. After all, if a police officer obtained evidence without permission, their findings would be deemed inadmissible.

Let’s take a look at a few instances in which information a private investigator uncovers can and should be used in trial.

When is Private Investigator Evidence Legal in Court?

Since private investigators are private citizens, they are not bound by the Fourth Amendment. Therefore, information uncovered is admissible in court, without the consent of the investigated party. There are, however, limitations.

When individuals are observed or heard in a public place, anything they say or do can be entered as evidence. Conversations overheard and pictures captured are generally legal and admissible. For instance, if someone is seen or heard incriminating themselves at a crowded restaurant, they do not have a “legitimate expectation of privacy in the communication.” If they are, however, in the comfort of their own home, any evidence collected would be considered a violation of privacy and would be inadmissible in a court of law.

If you’re considering hiring a private investigator, but are concerned about the legal parameters, it’s always best to consult with an attorney first. 

When you're ready to take the next steps and hire a private investigator, look no further than the certified experts at Same Day Process. Headquartered in the heart of Washington D.C., Same Day Process is the leading provider of fast and reliable process serving and legal support services in Maryland, Virginia, and across the United States.

Mobile Notary Services FAQs

Originally published ​March 1, 2016. Last updated April 30, 2023. Mobile notary services provide a convenient and accessible option for individuals who require notarial acts but cannot travel to a traditional notary's office or need...

The Importance of Process Serving in Legal System

Originally published 01/19/2016. Last updated 04/05/2023. The United States judicial system operates on the principles of fairness and due process. This system aims to ensure that all parties involved in a legal case receive equal and...

What Happens If I Avoid A Process Server?

Original Post: 07/31/2017 If you are looking to sue someone, divorce them, obtain child support, or many other legal issues, you may attempt to have the papers served to them. A process server can be hired to track them down and serve the...

5 Things Private Investigators Can and Can't Do

Originally posted on 11/08/2016 Have you been frustrated with a case that doesn't move forward? Many people dealing with a stuck case might consider hiring a private investigator. These professionals have a large amount of...

What should I expect from my process server?

Navigating the legal world is a challenge, but finding an experienced, reliable, and knowledgeable process server shouldn’t be. Here at Same Day Process, we treat each client as our only client and go above and beyond to assure each case is...

The Signs of a Trustworthy Process Server

Blog originally published on December 11, 2015. Updated on December 8, 2022. When beginning legal proceedings, it’s extremely important to have an iron-clad process serving procedure in place for any legal document you need to deliver....
Page: 123456 - All